Brooklyn Pickle Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Introducing the Menu at Brooklyn Pickle

Located at 600 State St, Utica, NY, Brooklyn Pickle is a delightful haven for sandwich lovers. The menu is a testament to deli-style craftsmanship, featuring a range of giant sandwiches, subs, and wraps that make every bite memorable. Signature offerings like the Reuben and Brooklyn Pickle Special showcase fresh ingredients, with corned beef, Swiss cheese, and house-made Russian dressing layered on dark rye bread.

With items priced between $6.35 and $9.50, Brooklyn Pickle provides a diverse selection catering to all tastes, from hearty meats to vegetarian options.

The restaurant boasts a vibrant atmosphere, including options for outdoor seating, making it a great spot for casual dining or takeout. Patrons rave about the exceptional service and the welcoming vibe, making every visit a joyful experience. Enjoy a taste of tradition at Brooklyn Pickle—where every sandwich is crafted with care!

Giant Sandwiches Giant Subs Giant Wraps Homemade Soups Sides and Salads Beverages Chips Pickles Desserts

Giant Sandwiches

Reuben Sandwich

Comes with corned beef, Swiss cheese and Russian. Hot on dark rye bread.
$9.25

Brooklyn Pickle Special Sandwich

Comes with corned beef, pastrami, Russian dressing and Swiss Cheese on dark rye bread.
$8.75

Pastrami Sandwich
$8.75

Turkey Breast Sandwich
$8.75

Cajun Turkey Breast Sandwich
$8.75

Roast Beef Sandwich
$8.75

Corned Beef Sandwich
$8.75

Chicken Salad Sandwich
$7.75

Roast Pork Sandwich
$7.75

Italian Sandwich

comes with capocollo, salami,provolone cheese, shredded lettuce, Italian tomatoes
$7.75

Cappocollo Sandwich
$7.75

BLT Sandwich

Bacon, lettuce and tomato.
$7.75

Seafood Salad Sandwich
$7.25

Ham Salad Sandwich
$7.25

Ham and Cheese Sandwich
$7.25

Tuna Salad Sandwich
$7.25

Hard Salami Sandwich
$7.25

Cheese Sandwich
$6.35

Vegetarian Sandwich
$6.35

Egg and Olive Sandwich
$6.35

Bologna Sandwich
$6.35

Liverwurst Sandwich
$6.35

Brooklyn Pickle Special Sub

Comes with corned beef, pastrami, Russian and Swiss cheese on dark rye bread.
$8.25

Pastrami Sub
$8.25

Turkey Breast Sub
$8.25

Cajun Turkey Breast Sub
$8.25

Roast Beef Sub
$8.25

Corned Beef Sub
$8.25

Chicken Salad Sub
$7.75

Roast Pork Sub
$7.75

BLT Sub

Bacon, lettuce and tomato.
$7.75

Italian Sub

Comes with Cappocollo, Salami, Provolone cheese, shredded Lettuce, Italian tomatoes
$7.75

Cappocollo Sub
$7.75

Seafood Salad Sub
$7.25

Ham Salad Sub
$7.25

Tuna Salad Sub
$7.25

Hard Salami Sub
$7.25

Cheese Sub
$6.00

Vegetarian Sub
$6.00

Egg and Olive Sub
$6.00

Bologna Sub
$6.00

Liverwurst Sub
$6.00

Meatballs with Provolone on 8" Roll
$9.50

Ham and Cheese Sub
$7.25

Giant Subs

Giant Wraps

Brooklyn Pickle Special

Comes with Corned Beef, Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Rye Bread, Russian Dressing
$9.25

Chicken Salad
$9.25

Roast Pork
$9.25

Pastrami
$9.25

Turkey Breast
$9.25

Roast Beef
$9.25

Corned Beef
$9.25

Italian

Comes with provolone cheese, Salami, Capocollo, shredded lettuce, & Italian tomatoes
$9.25

Capocollo
$9.25

Seafood salad
$9.25

Ham Salad
$9.25

Ham & Cheese
$9.25

Tuna Salad
$9.25

Hard Salami
$9.25

Cheese
$9.25

Vegetarian
$9.25

Egg & Olive
$9.25

Bologna
$9.25

Liverwurst
$9.25

BLT
$9.25

Chicken Noodle Soup

if you would like to know what our other soups are for the day please call 315-624-0300! Specify in the special instructions what soup you are looking for please
$4.50

Chili
$5.00

Neptune Stew

seafood, shrimp, clams, green peppers, & onions in a tomato sauce
$5.00

Daily Special

Please call the restaurant to see what are special of the day is 315-624-0300
$5.50

Homemade Soups

Sides and Salads

Salad du Jour

Please call the restaurant for daily salad selection.
$10.75

Julienne Salad
$9.95

Antipasto Salad
$9.95

Chef Salad with scoop of Chicken Salad
$9.95

Chef Salad with scoop of Tuna
$9.95

Chef Salad with scoop of Seafood
$9.95

Chef Salad
$7.95

Small Chef Salad
$5.95

Homemade Pasta Salad
$3.00

Homemade Potato Salad
$3.00

Homemade Baked Beans
$3.00

Homemade Coleslaw
$3.00

Homemade Macaroni Salad
$3.00

20 oz. Bottled Soda
$3.00

Aquafina Water
$3.00

Chocolate Milk
$3.45

Gatorade
$3.00

Pure Leaf Tea
$3.00

Beverages

Chips

2 oz. Dirty Chips Sea Salt
$3.25

2 oz. Dirty Chips Pepper and Sea Salt
$3.25

2 oz. Dirty Chips Sour Cream and Onion
$3.25

2 oz. Dirty Chips Mesquite BBQ
$3.25

2 oz. Dirty Chips Jalapeno
$3.25

2 oz. Dirty Chips Salt and Vinegar
$3.25

2oz Dirty Chips Sriracha honey
$3.25

2oz Dirty chip Funky Fusion
$3.25

2oz Dirty chip Maui onion
$3.25

Dirty chip sea salt 4.75oz
$4.50

Dirty chip mesquite bbq 4.75oz
$4.50

Dirty chip salt & vinegar 4.75oz
$4.50

Dirty chip cracked pepper & sea salt 4.75oz
$4.50

Whole Dill Pickle
$3.00

Brooklyn Full Sour Pickle
$3.00

Quart of Full Sour Pickles
$8.95

Cup of sliced Full Sour Pickles
$3.00

Cup of sliced dill pickles
$3.00

Pickles

Desserts

Chocolate Pudding
$4.55

Rice Pudding
$4.55

Big Cheesecake with Berries
$6.15

Big plain NY style Cheesecake
$5.70

Homemade Brownie with Walnuts
$2.50

Cream Cheese Brownie
$3.25

Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.50